Indonesian President Joko Widodo (Jokowi) has announced a comprehensive package of reforms aimed at reducing inflation and stabilising the exchange rate, stimulating demand through ‘deregulation’ and direct support, with a special focus on creating more jobs in small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and across urban and rural communities. The reforms will come into effect tomorrow, Tuesday September 15, 2015.
The package is enormous in scope and encompasses many existing government initiatives. It is to be part of a series of packages, so may be only the icing on the cake. But one thing is clear: it is a different package of ‘deregulation’ reforms from that first announced in the second half of the 1980s when Indonesia’s economy appeared similarly to be on its knees. Now the focus is more on public sector support and increasing demand, rather than market oriented reforms to improve competitiveness.
The reforms need to be placed in context. Indonesia’s economy is not suffering a major meltdown. Growth is lackluster, but steady, inflation relatively high, but under control, and there’s been no major shock to the Indonesia labour market. But Indonesia’s economy is growing slower than under Jokowi’s predecessor Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono (SBY) and the macroeconomic situation is weaker than when Jokowi came to power almost 12 months ago.
Indonesia GDP growth is running at around 4.5 per cent, not the 5 to 6 per cent of earlier years. Annual inflation of almost 7 per cent in August 2015 is higher than almost all Indonesia’s neighbours and trading partners, thus undermining the potential competitive gains from the rupiah’s 12-month depreciation.
The fall below Rp14,000 to the US dollar in August has reminded people of the trauma of the 1998 Asian financial crisis, the last occasion when the rupiah hit such levels.
Wide Range of Reforms
To reduce inflation and stabilise the exchange rate, Bank Indonesia (BI) proposed a wide range of reforms. This included more collaboration with regional governments in seeking to control local prices, controlling beef prices, and seeking to reduce rupiah instability through secondary and bonds markets.
The import bans and controls of a range of basic food commodities — which have recently had the main impact on inflation — were not addressed directly in the reform package.
To improve the domestic supply of foreign currency, foreign nationals will no longer need special permission to open bank accounts in foreign currency up to a limit of US$50,000.
The ‘deregulation’ program announced appears massive, mostly aimed at reducing regulatory overlap. Many of these measures have been in the pipeline for several months. One test will be how quickly they can come into operation given the time taken to draft new legislation in Indonesia.
Other direct government intervention is mooted to come from accelerating and extending existing national strategic projects through administrative reforms and boosting government investment in the property sector.
New efforts to stimulate spending and create more jobs are welcome, but it’s unclear that the anticipated reforms will help solve layoffs in industries affected by declining international prices or loss of competitiveness.
By mid-2015, signs of a rapidly weakening Indonesia labour market were emerging. After years of falling unemployment and recovering formal sector jobs, employment growth began to increase by less than one per cent annually on average in 2012–14, compared with labour force growth of closer to two per cent annually.
There have been substantial layoffs in the coal industry and also in the manufacturing sector close to Jakarta.
A short-term boost to demand can be expected from raising the tax free threshold from Rp2.4 to Rp3.6 million, which is likely to now cover almost all unskilled workers. Jobs and incomes will also receive a boost through subsidised government credit to SMEs and exporters and subsidies to companies threatening lay-offs.
At the community level cash-for-work schemes are to be funded through the large new Village Subsidy Fund (Dana Desa), recently proposed by former finance minister Chatib Basri. Pro-poor initiatives include an extra two months subsidised rice for poor households. The government has also promised schemes to lower the cost of fuel for fishermen and government support for the suffering shipbuilding industry.
The disarray in currency and stock markets on August 24, 2015 undoubtedly spooked the government after months of stop-start policies. The new reforms are ostensibly to improve both confidence and lure more investment.
Yet there is so far little evidence that the reforms reflect the government’s commitment to more openness and deregulation rather than more of a knee jerk reaction to short-term problems of financial instability.
What can this first package be expected to achieve?
For a start it will give money markets and investors some confidence in the new cabinet after the August reshuffle, especially the economics team under Darmin Nasution. But there are worries.
Efforts to improve international competitiveness seem absent, for now. Old, popular remedies that have not been easy to implement in the past have also resurfaced, such as subsidised credit for SMEs and support for cooperatives.
The government has been stronger on announcements than implementation, so this will be the thing to watch. Investors will need more signs of a committed and consistent program of reform if the government is to begin to turn things around in the medium to longer term.
It has tended to buckle in the face of criticism, such as backsliding on its plan to undertake regular price adjustments of fuel in line with international price movements in early 2015. Other examples are wildly fluctuating quotas for beef imports, and chopping and changing regulations on foreign workers and mineral ores.
Hopefully, Jokowi’s first package is just the beginning, as the government gears up to turning around Indonesia’s economy.
This article was written by Chris Manning, a former head of the Indonesian Project and adjunct associate professor at the Australian National University (ANU). This article first appeared on East Asia Forum under a Creative Commons license and is reproduced here with its permission
- Lacklustre Indonesia tries to boost economy with reforms (The Financial Times)
- Indonesian Stocks Slide Into Bear Market as Economy Stumbles (Bloomberg)
- Jokowi seeks Saudi investors to hasten Indonesia’s growth (Saudi Gazette)
Latest posts by East Asia Forum (see all)
- Can Mahathir and PH Bring Down UMNO’s Corrupt Party-state? - September 7, 2017
- Indonesia’s Digital Economy: Bridging The Digital Divide - September 4, 2017
- Indonesia Still Haunted by Asian Financial Crisis Ghosts - August 28, 2017
- Cooperation & Struggle: Vietnam’s South China Sea Strategy - August 14, 2017